Cracker Barrel’s Rebrand Sparks Backlash: When Nostalgia Meets Modernization

The rebranding of Cracker Barrel has been making headlines for the past few days and is widely criticized on social media.

The company’s $700 million overhaul, which includes a new logo and restaurant redesigns, has left many people wondering if modernization is worth the cost of lost heritage.

Here’s what happened and why so many people are confused and upset.

Proven Systems for Business Owners, Marketers, and Agencies
→ Our mini-course helps you audit and refine an existing brand in 15 days, just 15 minutes a day.
→ The Ultimate Brand Building System is your step-by-step blueprint to building and scaling powerful brands from scratch.

Key Facts

• Cracker Barrel is an iconic chain of restaurants and gift stores from the U.S.A., with a Southern country theme.
• A week ago (on Tuesday, August 19th, 2025), the brand introduced its redesigned logo, transforming it into a simpler wordmark.
• This update is part of a $700 million rebrand. It comes about a year after Cracker Barrel began refreshing its brand, which included remodeling many restaurants. The goal is to make locations brighter and more modern to appeal to new customers. The locations are getting rid of old dark wood and vintage decorations for a brighter, simpler look.
• The new logo has already sparked backlash online, especially from some conservative voices, but also from loyal customers. Social media is full of strong reactions, from jokes to anger, with some bringing up old controversies.
• Following the announcement, Cracker Barrel’s stock dropped over 11% by Thursday, August 21st, 2025.
• In response, Cracker Barrel told Forbes the new logo is a “call-back to the original,” insisting that “the heart and soul of Cracker Barrel haven’t changed.” The company added that Uncle Herschel, the man featured in the old logo, “remains front and center in our restaurants and on our menu.”

The Company’s Reasons Behind the Rebrand

Cracker Barrel has seen its traditional approach lose resonance with customers, according to its new CEO.

For the past few years, executives have noted that their “traditionalist” customers (those 65 and older) have been slower to return to dine in person since the Covid-19 pandemic. According to CBS News, 2024 sales have stagnated, and the company’s stock price has dropped by 40% in 2024. Cracker Barrel has also lost market share, especially during dinner hours.

“We are not leading in any area,” Masino said. “The reality is we’ve lost some market share, especially at dinner.”

Source: CBS News

In response to these main challenges, the company announced a brand refresh last year. This three-year modernization effort began in 2024 and aims to attract younger and higher-income customers while retaining the traditional ones. The changes include brighter, more contemporary restaurant designs with fewer antiques, menu updates featuring broader and lighter options, and optimized kitchen processes. The rebrand now continues with a logo redesign.

Some longtime customers have voiced concerns about losing the nostalgic country atmosphere. However, The Wall Street Journal reports that early results from revamped locations show higher sales and improved customer traffic.

Cracker Barrel is also facing broader industry challenges such as inflation and changing consumer habits, making it harder to keep customers returning. The chain is also dealing with new tariffs on retail merchandise and economic uncertainty. Its lower average prices compared to its competitors offers some pricing flexibility, but ongoing issues with pricing and menu options persist. Ultimately, executives remain focused on balancing value, convenience, quality, and a welcoming feel to attract new customers and grow the business in a challenging environment.

About the Brand

Cracker Barrel is a chain of American restaurants and gift stores known for its Southern country theme. It was founded in 1969 in Lebanon, Tennessee, and now has 660 locations across 45 states. The chain originally placed its restaurants near highways to attract travelers, but expanded nationwide in the 1990s and 2000s.

The menu at Cracker Barrel focuses on traditional Southern comfort food, such as biscuits, fried chicken, and catfish, with breakfast served all day. Each restaurant also has a gift shop that sells old-fashioned toys, puzzles, country music CDs, vintage candy, and home décor items that reflect a nostalgic style.

Each Cracker Barrel location is designed to feel like an old general store, decorated with antique items and local artifacts. The restaurants feature wooden rocking chairs on the porch, stone fireplaces, and classic decorations inside, including a peg solitaire game on every table. Authentic vintage items are stored in a warehouse in Tennessee and used to decorate each new location, creating a cozy and unique atmosphere for customers.

Cracker Barrel’s target audience includes families and people looking for a relaxed, casual dining experience, as well as shoppers interested in their retail items. The brand also focuses on attracting travelers, especially those driving on interstate highways, by placing most of its restaurants near highway exits.

The brand has always stood out for its food and its immersive, country-inspired experience. Visiting Cracker Barrel feels like stepping into a time capsule, a nice homage to Southern general stores and roadside hospitality.

What’s Changing at Cracker Barrel

A new campaign and rebrand plan

The “All the More” campaign and rebrand consist of the following main changes:

• The piloting of its restaurants remodeling, which involves “a different color palette, updating lighting, offering more comfortable seating and simplifying décor and fixtures.”, as featured on CBS News. Check one example here.
• Music from country music artist Jordan Davis
• New additions to the restaurants’ menus
• An “enhanced brand look and feel” including a change of logo.

The recent logo redesign

Regarding the logo, the brand chose to remove the design of the older man in overalls sitting next to a barrel. Many people believed this man was Uncle Herschel (a goodwill ambassador and the uncle of Cracker Barrel’s founder, Dan Evins). But in reality, he was drawn by Nashville designer Bill Holley in 1977, and was meant to give a nostalgic feel with an old-timer, not specifically Uncle Herschel.

The new logo is much simpler. It keeps just the company name in brown on a yellow background with a basic yellow shape suggesting a barrel. This change reflects Cracker Barrel’s goal to represent all its guests, not just one person, by celebrating the diversity of everyone who visits, no matter their background.

The use of barrels in their name and on their porches comes from the tradition of shipping soda crackers in barrels, which became meeting spots in those stores.

Cracker Barrel told CBS News that “Uncle Herschel,” the man shown in their logo, will continue to be a main feature in their restaurants and on their menu.

A Rebrand That’s Stirring Controversy

Despite the company reporting positive feedback from customers and store managers regarding the remodeling of the restaurants, the recent launch of the new logo has sparked fierce reactions online.

Loyal customers disapprove the loss of the brand’s unique “country kitsch” aesthetic. They see the new direction as soulless.

The brand has also been criticized by public figures, including political figures like Donald Trump Jr., who have tied the change to broader cultural shifts, accusing Cracker Barrel of abandoning tradition. The backlash has also brought up memories of past controversies and amplifies the feeling that Cracker Barrel is drifting from its roots. In other words, the brand’s new logo and location redesign have left many fans wondering if a slice of Americana is being erased in favor of bland modernity.

But some people on social media have also mocked the outrage, pointing out that every brand must adapt to survive.

Cracker Barrel’s response has tried to walk a fine line: recognizing fan concerns while defending the need for change. The company’s executives assure customers that many beloved features will still be found inside their restaurants, even if some visual symbols are gone. They clarified that while the visuals are evolving, the brand’s heart and soul, as well as its core values like Southern hospitality and comfort food, remain unchanged.

The company also said in an August 18th press release that the new logo is now even more closely based on the classic barrel shape and lettering that the brand started with.

“We believe in the goodness of country hospitality, a spirit that has always defined us,” said Sarah Moore, chief marketing officer of Cracker Barrel. “Our story hasn’t changed. Our values haven’t changed. With ‘All the More,’ we’re honoring our legacy  while bringing fresh energy, thoughtful craftsmanship and heartfelt hospitality to our guests this fall.”

Source: Cracker Barrel

In addition, they’ve published on Monday, August 25th 2025, a Facebook post designed as a letter to their customer, and in reaction to the current headlines affecting the brand:

The Financial Investment and Impact on The Brand So Far

The scale of Cracker Barrel’s $700 million brand refresh investment shows just how high the stakes are. This budget covers a 3-year rebrand, which started in 2024.

According to CBS News, Cracker Barrel grew quickly in the 1990s as it opened more locations, but its growth has slowed lately. In 2024, the company made about $3.5 billion in revenue, which is 0.8% higher than the $3.4 billion it made the year before. However, its net income dropped to $40.9 million, compared to $99 million in 2023.

Following the logo redesign announcement in August 2025, the restaurant’s stock fell about 7% on Thursday (representing a loss of nearly $100 million in market value), but recovered a bit on Friday.

What remains to be seen is how these modifications will impact the brand’s future sales and market shares. Because the brand has been losing relevance over the years and is planning on attracting new audiences, it will be important to give it some time to fully understand how this new strategic direction will translate into the market reality in the next few years.

Our Analysis and Key Takeaways

This isn’t the first time brands have underestimated sentimental attachment. We are thinking of New Coke’s failure in the 1980s, Tropicana’s packaging redesign failure, or Gap’s quickly abandoned logo change. Customers often feel betrayed or lost when familiar symbols vanish overnight. Even if the changes make sense on paper.

Cracker Barrel’s rebrand is a new example of a heritage brand underestimating the power of nostalgia and emotional connection with its core audience.

The disappointment began with subtle changes to store décor but peaked with the loss of Uncle Herschel and the barrel in the logo.

The debate here is not just about a missing barrel or an old-timer mascot in a logo, but rather about what happens when the soul of a brand is put at risk for the sake of modernization. By removing the brand’s iconic imagery and all the decoration details that made the restaurants’ atmosphere feel so unique, the brand is touching its own essence, and this can provoke strong emotions amongst customers. The company is losing some of its strongest differentiators (the brand’s symbols and unique atmospheric experience), and this puts it at risk of blending into the background. As more restaurant chains adopt minimalist logos and generic interiors, Cracker Barrel could lose what makes it truly unique.

That said, it is of course too soon to evaluate the real impact these changes will have on the brand. As explained earlier, the company is facing many financial challenges and needs to find a solution to attract new visitors. Refreshing the brand is not a bad idea, but each change should be done slowly, one after the other, and backed up with solid market research.

It’s also difficult to judge Cracker Barrel’s new strategy without knowing more about the brand’s new target audiences. Trying to appeal to everyone usually weakens a brand and blurs what makes it special. Cracker Barrel should clearly define who they want to focus on (whether it’s a new group or their loyal customers) and build their changes around that audience. With a clear focus, the brand can make wise choices, stay true to its identity, and create stronger connections with the customers that matter most.

Possibilities for the future

As Cracker Barrel responds to recent criticism over its rebrand, the company can follow several paths to strengthen its position and reconnect with customers. It can choose to go backwards, like Tropicana, Gap, or even Coke did in the past. Or it can choose to go forward with the changes. In that case, we are sharing below some ideas and alternative strategies the brand could explore, moving forward:

• Actively involve both loyal and potential new guests by gathering feedback through surveys, focus groups, or design contests, allowing customers to help shape the brand’s evolution while protecting its key assets.
• Phase in changes gradually to preserve the emotional connection with longtime guests.
• Deepen marketing storytelling around Cracker Barrel’s heritage by sharing authentic stories about Uncle Herschel, the barrel tradition, and the brand’s community roots across social media and in-store experiences.
• Do the same for the brand’s evolution: transparently communicate everything, over and over. Listen to feedback and adjust the strategies accordingly.
• Test softer approaches to modernization, such as leveraging influencer partnerships and new communication channels to reach younger or more diverse audiences.
• Launch limited-time menu collaborations or regional specialties to attract new customers and create excitement without disrupting the familiar atmosphere regulars love.
• Consider pursuing a hybrid strategy that maintains classic décor and branding at flagship or high-traffic locations, while piloting new concepts in select stores to test customer response before rolling out broader changes.

Final thoughts

Cracker Barrel’s rebrand is another reminder that brands are not just logos, color schemes, and visual aesthetics. They’re living stories and experiences that create memories and emotions in people’s lives.

The backlash shows how risky it can be to change what customers hold dear to their hearts. While innovation is of course necessary for survival, brands must remember that, sometimes, the old barrel out front and the vintage treasures on the walls can have more worth than all the touches designed to modernize them. Only the future will tell us how the brand’s new target audiences will react to this strategic shift.